Spreadsheet vs Attendance Software: When It's Time to Switch
A spreadsheet is a perfectly fine attendance system for a while. Here are the specific signs it's stopped being one, and what a growing team actually gains by switching.
By Presentee Team · August 25, 2026 · 2 min read
Bring-your-own-device is the default for attendance apps for a good reason — buying and managing company phones for every employee is expensive and, for most small and mid-sized companies, unnecessary. But BYOD without any device controls at all creates a specific, predictable set of problems that only show up after they've already caused an issue: a payroll dispute, an attendance record nobody can verify, or a departing employee who still technically has access.
If an employee's login credentials work from any phone with the app installed, then anyone with those credentials — the employee, a coworker they trust, or someone who found a written-down password — can produce a valid-looking attendance record. This is the direct technical cause of buddy punching in a digital system: no device restriction means the login is the only barrier, and logins get shared far more casually than most managers assume.
Without device-level tracking, there's no clean way to know which physical phone is still logged into the company's attendance system. An employee who upgrades phones and sells the old one, without explicitly signing out first, may leave a working session on a device that's no longer theirs. A device-approval system solves this structurally: attendance only comes from one recognized device at a time, and replacing it is a deliberate, logged action — a new device request that revokes the old one the moment it's approved.
This is one of the more overlooked risks of loose device management: when someone leaves the company, is their access actually cut off, or just their login credentials disabled while a session on their personal phone technically remains valid until it happens to expire? A proper device-approval model ties revocation to the device record directly — deactivating the employee should immediately invalidate whatever device was approved for them, not leave it in an ambiguous state.
None of this requires abandoning BYOD — it requires treating 'which device' as data the system tracks and controls, the same way it already tracks location and identity.
It adds one step — an admin approving the employee's first device — but this is typically fast, often just a few minutes, and it's a natural moment to happen anyway since the admin is already setting up the new employee's account.
A spreadsheet is a perfectly fine attendance system for a while. Here are the specific signs it's stopped being one, and what a growing team actually gains by switching.
Leave tracked in a group chat works for exactly as long as everyone remembers to check it. Here's what to put in place before that stops being true.
The formula for attendance percentage is simple. Getting it right in practice — leave days, holidays, partial attendance — is where most spreadsheets quietly go wrong.
Set up your workspace now and add your team as you grow. No card, no sales call.